| Player | Goals | First Goal | Last Goal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josh King | 48 | 21-Nov-15 | 26-Jul-20 |
| Callum Wilson | 41 | 22-Aug-15 | 07-Mar-20 |
| Dominic Solanke | 27 | 12-Jul-20 | 11-May-24 |
| Junior Stanislas | 21 | 28-Nov-15 | 26-Jul-20 |
| Ryan Fraser | 16 | 04-Dec-16 | 15-Sep-19 |
| Dan Gosling | 12 | 26-Sep-15 | 01-Jul-20 |
| Nathan Aké | 11 | 19-Nov-16 | 01-Feb-20 |
| Benik Afobe | 10 | 16-Jan-16 | 22-Apr-17 |
| Philip Billing | 10 | 01-Feb-20 | 09-Dec-23 |
| Steve Cook | 10 | 12-Sep-15 | 23-Nov-19 |
| Charlie Daniels | 9 | 19-Dec-15 | 30-Jan-19 |
| Antoine Semenyo | 9 | 30-Apr-23 | 24-Apr-24 |
| David Brooks | 9 | 01-Oct-18 | 02-Sep-23 |
| Jefferson Lerma | 8 | 10-Nov-18 | 30-Apr-23 |
| Marcus Tavernier | 8 | 05-Nov-22 | 06-Apr-24 |
| Justin Kluivert | 7 | 25-Nov-23 | 28-Apr-24 |
| Harry Wilson | 7 | 17-Aug-19 | 21-Jan-20 |
| Marcos Senesi | 6 | 11-Feb-23 | 28-Apr-24 |
| Marc Pugh | 5 | 22-Aug-15 | 22-Apr-17 |
| Adam Smith | 5 | 28-Nov-15 | 15-Sep-18 |
| Kieffer Moore | 5 | 06-Aug-22 | 06-Dec-23 |
| Matt Ritchie | 4 | 19-Sep-15 | 07-May-16 |
| Jermain Defoe | 4 | 15-Sep-17 | 31-Mar-18 |
| Lys Mousset | 3 | 03-Feb-18 | 27-Feb-19 |
| Jaidon Anthony | 3 | 03-Sep-22 | 21-Jan-23 |
| Glenn Murray | 3 | 03-Oct-15 | 05-Dec-15 |
| Harry Arter | 3 | 12-Jan-16 | 18-Nov-17 |
| Jordon Ibe | 3 | 14-Jan-18 | 12-May-19 |
| Drew Surman | 2 | 15-Sep-17 | 21-Oct-17 |
| Dango Ouattara | 2 | 15-Apr-23 | 09-Mar-24 |
| Enes Ünal | 2 | 09-Mar-24 | 28-Apr-24 |
| Luis Sinisterra | 2 | 04-Nov-23 | 26-Dec-23 |
| Matías Viña | 2 | 15-Apr-23 | 06-May-23 |
| Chris Mepham | 1 | 10-Aug-19 | 10-Aug-19 |
| Illia Zabarnyi | 1 | 13-Mar-24 | 13-Mar-24 |
| Tommy Elphick | 1 | 23-Apr-16 | 23-Apr-16 |
| Max Gradel | 1 | 12-Mar-16 | 12-Mar-16 |
| Ryan Christie | 1 | 08-Oct-22 | 08-Oct-22 |
| Alex Scott | 1 | 31-Dec-23 | 31-Dec-23 |
